The McKinsey Quarterly

  • Recommend
  • Text Size
  • Print
  • Download PDF
  • Link to This

How private health care can help Africa

In Nigeria, Kenya, and elsewhere, the private sector already serves more than 40 percent of the people in the lowest economic quintile. With the right investments, it could do even more.

Health Care, Strategy & Analysis article, private health care Africa

In This Article

Audio

audio MP3 How private health care can help Africa

To use the audio player, please install the Adobe Flash Player plugin version 9 or greater.

Download MP3

Although much of the attention on health care in sub-Saharan Africa centers on government activity, the private sector plays a surprisingly significant and growing role in meeting the region’s health care needs. Indeed, our research, conducted in partnership with the International Finance Corporation (IFC) and the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, found that the increasing demand for health care due to improved economic growth across much of the region could translate into $20 billion of additional investment in the region’s private-sector health care infrastructure in the coming decade.

To understand how the private health sector (by which we mean all nonpublic health care activity1) might better complement Africa’s public health systems, we studied the health care sectors of 45 sub-Saharan African countries.2 The findings suggest opportunities for private enterprise to help improve the region’s woefully poor health outcomes.3 At the same time, the research also highlights challenges—such as inconsistent quality of care, health worker shortages, and inadequate regulation—that must be addressed if the private sector is to most effectively benefit the health of Africa’s people.

Sub-Saharan Africa’s private health sector is already large and diverse. Of the $16.7 billion in total health expenditures in 2005, about 60 percent was privately financed and about half of the spending went to private providers (Exhibit 1). Perhaps surprisingly, our study confirms that the private sector doesn’t primarily serve the wealthy. In Ethiopia, Nigeria, Kenya, and Uganda, for example, the World Bank found that more than 40 percent of people in the lowest economic quintile receive health care from private, for-profit providers. Still, the private sector’s role in individual countries varies widely because of political, historical, and economic factors. In Ghana and Uganda, for example, private-sector usage exceeds 60 percent; in Namibia it’s less than 10 percent.

In the coming decade, sub-Saharan Africa’s health care market will grow briskly, and the private sector’s share of it will increase as improved macroeconomic conditions in much of the region4 fuel rising demand for health care. Our research suggests that sub-Saharan Africa’s health care expenditures will more than double by 2016, to $35 billion a year. The private sector will likely garner 60 percent of this amount.

To meet the increased demand, about $25 billion to $30 billion in total incremental investment is required by 2016 to finance physical assets such as hospitals, clinics, and drug-distribution centers. Governments will certainly receive some of this investment. However, in countries receptive to private-sector activity, we expect that between 45 and 70 percent of the funds will be invested in the private sector. Regionally, this equates to between $11 billion and $20 billion over the next 10 years.

Health care provision will account for half of the total investment opportunity, with the remainder divided among distribution and retailing (for instance, of pharmaceuticals and equipment), life sciences (such as pharmaceuticals and medical-product manufacturing), risk pooling, and medical education (Exhibit 2). The largest individual investments will likely focus on capacity expansion (for example, adding hospital beds), while significant investment will also go to refurbishing existing assets, increasing working capital, expanding services, and pursuing new ventures. While most projects will be small (under $3 million), many will be financially viable (Exhibit 3).

But will the investments positively affect the health of Africa’s people? Here, our study confirms the findings of the World Bank and other researchers that suggest the private sector can play a diverse and meaningful role, say by making care more readily available to poor and rural populations, potentially raising the quality of available care, providing additional medical training capacity,5 and efficiently managing costs. Our study underscored the fact that millions of Africans each day choose private providers over public ones, and primary research we conducted in rural Tanzania showed that up to three-quarters of patients prefer private providers and drug dispensaries to public alternatives—citing convenience and quality of care, among other benefits. Moreover, private clinics are frequently better supplied with medicines than are their public counterparts.

Tempering this optimism, however, is our study’s confirmation of the private sector’s shortcomings, which can include inconsistent levels of care, inefficiency, and unethical business practices, such as drug counterfeiting. Such shortcomings are all too common in sub-Saharan Africa’s diverse, highly fragmented, and often unregulated private health sector.

Addressing the challenges and ensuring the responsible mobilization of the region’s private health sector will require action from public and private stakeholders alike. Governments should modify local regulations that impede the development of the private health sector (say, trade barriers that limit access to health supplies or laws that restrict the private sector’s role in medical training or its participation in risk-pooling plans) and also strengthen regulatory bodies that can work with reputable businesses to better develop and enforce quality standards. Private donors and governments should consider earmarking aid to directly support private-sector entities, and also expand risk-pooling arrangements.

Indeed, we believe that the private sector’s size, vibrancy, and potential require that the dialogue on health in sub-Saharan Africa includes innovative public-private collaboration. Our study underscores the important role that policymakers, donors, and investors must together play in shaping Africa’s public and private sectors to deliver the improvements in health care that Africans deserve. mckinsey logo

About the Authors

Arnab Ghatak is an associate principal in McKinsey’s New Jersey office, where Judith Hazlewood is a director and Tony Lee is a consultant. The full report, The Business of Health in Africa: Partnering with the Private Sector to Improve People’s Lives, is available free of charge on ifc.org.

Notes

1For the purposes of this study, we defined the private sector as including for-profit organizations, nonprofits (including private donors, nongovernmental organizations, and faith-based organizations), and social enterprises.

2The study focused on five subsectors: health services, risk pooling, life sciences, distribution and retail, and medical education. Moreover, we conducted about 400 interviews with relevant stakeholders and supplemented these findings with a quantitative look at the region’s requirements for health care investment. Given the broad geographic scope of the project, our most detailed analysis was limited to the Democratic Republic of the Congo, Ghana, Kenya, Mozambique, Nigeria, Rwanda, Senegal, South Africa (for analysis of pharmaceuticals and medical-equipment manufacturing only), Tanzania, and Uganda. Our interviewees included stakeholders from private health enterprises, government officials and policymakers, development organizations, and financing institutions, in addition to health care experts and operators outside the region.

3Sub-Saharan Africa accounts for 11 percent of the world’s population, yet bears 24 percent of the global disease burden and commands less than 1 percent of global health expenditures.

4Sub-Saharan Africa’s nominal rate of GDP growth over the past 7 years was 5 percent; over the previous 20 years real GDP grew 0.2 percent a year. Moreover, over the past 7 years inflation in the region has dropped from 16 percent to less than 8 percent.

5See Michael D. Conway, Srishti Gupta, and Kamiar Khajavi, “Addressing Africa’s health workforce crisis,” mckinseyquarterly.com, November 2007.

Recommend
Comments
Submit Your Comments

The user information you enter into this form will not update your site profile. To update your profile, please visit your profile page.

Subject How private health care can help Africa

*Required

We may publish your comments online and in the print edition of McKinsey Quarterly. Those chosen, which may be edited for length and clarity, will appear along with your name and details, but not your e-mail address. We will use your e-mail address only to send you a confirmation copy of your comments and to notify you if we publish them online.

We value your feedback and will consider it carefully. Nonetheless, we receive so many comments that we cannot acknowledge all of them.

See also:
Preview

New In:
Embed E-mail